WordPress is a sect led by Messiah Matt Mullenweg
since the introduction of WP 5.0 & Gutenberg
The WP 5.0 Gutenberg train wreck
Gutenberg rating keeps dropping: now down to 1.9 stars
‘Gutenberg’ is the name of the new ‘flagship’ editor in WordPress (as from version 5.0). The name itself is a grave insult to the man who – in his time – revolutionized the way information is spread.
UPDATE March 15, 2019: Gutenberg is now down to a 1.9 stars rating…
4 and 5 star reviews: a little over 21% of all votes.
1 and 2 star reviews: a little over 75% of all votes.
Keep in mind, most 5-star reviews were submitted when Gutenberg was still in its testing phase (before forced into core), in stark contrast to the 1-star reviews.
I always told my clients: “Don’t worry, updating your website is as easy as writing a Word-document.” It no longer is. I cannot tell them that anymore. I have to educate them on ‘blocks’, how to arrange them, and that every single paragraph they write is a ‘block’. Not to mention: oh, but you have to ‘hover’ over these blocks to see the options. You know, uhm, an image block, just uhm, … oh shit, even I as a developer hate working with this totally unintuitive ‘editor’. I’m not the only one. Read a recent review of despicable Gutenberg: Good luck teaching your customers how to keep their website updated (with an added review post which says: “I have around 150 clients using WP – NOT ONE – NOT ONE – wants to continue using Gutenberg.”).
As the reviewer in the above link indicates, WordPress version 5 (and I’m afraid, beyond) is no longer THE Content Management System to advise to my clients. I’m certainly not the only one, but Gutenberg authors simply say: Hey man, it’s the future man, you know… Yes, that’s deliberately in 60’s style language, because that’s what Gutenberg is: going back, not forward. As is perfectly explained here: “Thanks to Gutenberg WordPress became a blog engine again” and here: “WordPress got the 10 year challenge wrong. You are not supposed to set back your business by 10 years”.
To me Gutenberg is like WordPress trying to re-invent the wheel. “Let’s make a square wheel, see what that does… Oh yeah man! Out of this world, awesome! The wobbling and tottering feels so much better, don’t you think?”
I was ‘flagged’ and subsequently banned on wordpress.org (reviews of Gutenberg and on the Forum) many times. Yes, I’ve created different GMail accounts in the hope to finally get the message through, but I’ve given up now, because those people just do not want to hear anything that doesn’t comply with the ‘vision’ they’ve set out.
Or should I say, the ‘vision’ by their Messiah?
Negative reviews of Gutenberg
are actively removed on wordpress.org
I was not banned for being abusive or using foul language. I can completely understand they don’t accept that. No, I was banned for being too critical (in the eyes of ‘moderators’) of the new Gutenberg editor. I’ve seen it happening to other posters and reviewers as well. Any post that’s considered ‘too critical’, ‘not making sense’, ‘not adding to the conversation’, ‘not a real review’, or anything else that falls in the ‘undesirable’ category is actively removed by WordPress moderators.
E.g. a 1-star negative review of Gutenberg saying only: ‘It sucks!’ would get removed (not adding anything to reviews, right?). Another review – with 5 stars – only saying: ‘Kick Ass!’ would stay (because that adds so much more to reviews, right?), and even get an author’s or moderator’s reply like: “Thank you!” I’m not kidding you. Not that there are many of those positive reviews, though…
The point is: WordPress keeps the rating of its new editor artificially high (well, if you’d think
2 stars 1.9 stars is high, that is…).
Especially WordPress ‘Moderator’ (or, as he labels himself: ‘Brute Squad and Volunteer Moderator’) Jan Dembowski (@jdembowski) seems totally pissed off with the huge wave of negative comments and is – on his own – pro-actively removing 1-star reviews. He wrote: too many of them are not feedback, they’re just rage posting (it was here but apparently it has been removed; should have kept screenshots of it…).
Anyway: really, mr. Moderator? And where do you think that rage comes from? Who are you to label these reviews as ‘not feedback’? God himself, or what?
This Dembowski figure has deleted another post by himself on that review link above where he announced he would remove all ‘non-essential’ reviews AND report all those accounts to be flagged and banned. Where does that put WordPress right now? In my book that is akin to a sect, where every critic, every deviation from the official rule, everyone not obeying the Messiah, everyone raging, everyone not fully complying with the ‘vision’ is ridiculed, set aside, and even – yes, I’m going to use the word – killed (as in: your review is removed and your wordpress.org account is killed instantly).
In the normal world, but probably not the Automattic world, it’s called censorship.
By the way, what’s that ‘Brute Squad’ thing in Dembowski’s profile? Is it something like the ‘brown shirts’ in nazi-Germany, removing all ‘unwanted’ elements?
It certainly feels that way, as all so-called WordPress ‘Moderators’ are seemingly blindly following The Leader, also known (to them, apparently) as Messiah Matt Mullenweg.
Gutenberg authors and WordPress moderators
are totally ignoring their users
With those removals of negative reviews, I think they’re trying to keep the rating up as much as they can. You cannot have a 1.5 star rating for your new flagship ‘editor’, can you? Not that it helps much. With the wave of bad reviews, the rating of Gutenberg is now already down to 1.9 stars.
UPDATE on March 20, 2019: we’re getting close to 4x (FOUR TIMES!!!) the number of 1-star reviews compared to 5-star reviews for Gutenberg. Only
40 16 negative reviews more to reach that point. However, negative reviews are still actively removed by the WordPress Thought Police. Since almost reaching the four times 1-star reviews against the 5-star score even more active, it seems. You can spot it easily checking the numbers regularly (which I do): the number of 1-star reviews is jumping up and then, surprisingly, down again. There’s only one logical explanation for that: every ‘inconvenient’ or ‘undesirable’ 1-star review of WordPress Gutenberg is removed.
An inconvenient truth indeed: the WordPress censorship in action these days…
Oh well, whatever: if I come across a plug-in with the kind of rating depicted below, I’m not even considering installing it.
Furthermore, it’s getting quite close to the ‘80% rule’ WordPress itself has put on ‘new features’: if it reaches that point they ‘blew it’ (see further down in this article).
If you only count reviews since WordPress 5.0 was released (when Gutenberg was forced into core), it’s already close to that 1.5 stars, and way past the ‘80% rule’. Oops! One of the lowest ratings in the WordPress repository!
Not that those dictators that run WordPress nowadays care: the recently released WP 5.1 takes Gutenberg to ‘the next level‘ (read: even more intrusive and counter-intuitive on what you want to do on your website).
Don’t forget the accidental 5-star reviews of which there are quite a few. 5 stars is the default setting when posting a review, you have to manually change it to a lower rating. Why that is? I don’t know. The rating system would be much more accurate if WordPress would have an alert like “You forgot to give a rating”. This goes for other plugins as well, but in the case of Gutenberg I suppose they’re happy to keep the system as it is. Every 5 star review is a 5 star review, right? Even if it’s not meant to be. Here’s a list of 5-star reviews of WordPress Gutenberg that are clearly meant to be 1-star only:
- Useless, terrible
- Omits Multiple Plugins
- Cannot Publish
- This is So Bad
- The Most Bad Change of All Life
- Very Bad Idea
- Don’t Like It
- No, I will leave WordPress
- A Real Nightmare
And this is just a selection…
There’s another WordPress user who has noticed that. In his review (What we need, but not how we need it) this user writes: “what’s with automatically selecting 5 stars for the review? How many people didn’t see that, generating false 5-star reviews“.
Plus: many ‘undesirable’ 1-star reviews (see above) have already been removed. My guess is that it’s easily a hundred or more that have been eliminated. The number of 1-star reviews of WordPress Gutenberg is actually much higher than the official number displayed. And thus, the 80% rule of users disliking this new ‘feature’ was already reached long time ago. But that’s hidden, of course, thanks to the WordPress Thought Police.
Not good, eh? Oh, but not for Gutenberg authors or WordPress ‘Moderators’. They simply ignore those star ratings. Really? Yes, really. Matt Mullenweg and his disciples can and will not accept their new baby is thrown out. One of those ‘Moderators’ (or should we call them self-assigned gods?) @clorith wrote: “we don’t care about star ratings”. Again, I’m not kidding you. As the title of the thread on Gutenberg reviews goes: WordPress Gives Zero Fs.
And read the final post in that thread by another self-assigned god called: @otto42 “Continued calls in the reviews to roll it back are kind of wasted effort. It’s not rolling back. Adapt, or move on.” Or, in more popular terms: you users just shut up, understood? No surprise that with this encouraging post, he closed the thread. As the ‘WordPress gods’ can do…
Notice the other mention in that post by @otto42: “The new direction was decided and final years ago, when the work began.” It’s almost, no correction: it is laughable. Years working on the Gutenberg project and the result is what it is now? LOL!!! WordPress (read: Automattic, read: Matt Mullenweg) must have some really, really bad UI – User Interface – designers in the team, I cannot explain the Gutenberg train wreck otherwise.
WordPress and its ‘moderators’
are burying their heads in the sand
Lots of valid remarks by a WordPress user on Gutenberg is the wrong direction, such as:
You’re ignoring the first rule of business:
Quality is conformity to customer requirements.
See how this @otto42 (he’s a ‘Keymaster’ by the way, whatever that means) replies:
You’re ignoring the fact that WordPress isn’t a company. It’s open source software.
What a lame reply by this “Otto”. If you replace ‘customer’ with ‘user’ I suppose his reply means that user requirements are of no importance whatsoever for WordPress. Well, … just so you know!
He goes on insulting and alienating WordPress users:
If you want to move on, then move on. Won’t affect me or anybody else one bit.
Again, that basically means: just shut up! What’s the term for that again? Right: ignorance.
Plus he writes: Best of luck to you and your new software choices.
What’s the term for that again? Right: arrogance. He – and the rest of the Gutenberg fan boys – probably don’t know the meaning of pride comes before the fall.
Another example of how WordPress ‘moderators’ refuse to listen and just bury their heads in the sand on Fixing WordPress Forum. A user complains about how inserting ‘Read More’ is now more cumbersome: If it’s not a one click button with the mouse, you’ve made it more complex.
And Otto remains his ignorant and arrogant stance with this reply:
Well, that’s a view, certainly. You’re welcome to your opinions. I personally think blocks are easier …
What do we care what you personally think Otto? You should think about how the majority of WordPress users label Gutenberg. Hey god Otto, if you need me to spell it out for you: u-n-u-s-a-b-l-e and u-n-w-a-n-t-e-d.
WordPress has launched a new ‘Moderator’ (well, actually she’s officially only a ‘Participant’) called DesignSimply replying to every new negative review and asking questions like: “Do you think you could see a website builder that seamlessly integrates editing and that still has a lot of the ease of use for writing content?” Well, yes, dumbo. It’s called Elementor (which is like 100 times better than the crap the Gutenberg team came up with after ‘years of development’). It’s a PLUG-IN. It is a CHOICE. It’s NOT FORCED upon every user.
That’s the whole point of rage against Gutenberg: it’s forced upon everyone. In other words: every single user of WordPress has to use the clumsy, not intuitive, unwanted new ‘feature’. Or, to get rid of the ‘new vision’ madness called ‘Gutenberg’, you have to install a plug-in to disable it.
Think about it: you need a plug-in to disable something that’s at the core of a WordPress website. Correction: not just ‘something’, no, you need to disable something to get back to what is at the heart of any website, blog or whatever. It’s called ‘writing’. The software’s name is now getting hilarious: WordPress forces you to disable a core ‘feature’ to write … words. Maybe the WordPress Gutenberg fan boys should rename their software to BlockPress.
Thinking about the double meaning of that, it’s a very adequate name for the ‘New Content Vision’!
The fact that the plug-in ‘Classic Editor’ (DO NOT install that by the way, see a better alternative below) was written by the very same team that ‘developed’ Gutenberg clearly indicates they’re not so sure about their ‘new vision’. Yet, it’s pushed down everyone’s throat, no matter what.
Ah, WordPress has now found a new participant willing to act as moderator: Elias Gómez who replies to every new negative review with useless comments. E.g. his comment here reads: “You’re so wrong”. Translated: just shut up. Or here: “I think the new editor is more simple and more flexible”. We don’t care what you think Elias, what the (overwhelming) majority of users think is what matters. And, by the way, if you’re such a fan of Gutenberg, why didn’t you write a glowing review yourself? (FYI, he didn’t, his last review was 1 year and 8 months ago for a plug-in called, wait for it… “Page Builder by SiteOrigin”.)
And then he writes a copy and paste comment here, and here, and here: “What things you can’t do? With 5 minutes of testing you should be able to do the basic tasks”. I always thought copy/paste comments were prohibited on WordPress review pages. Oh well, I guess in the case of Gutenberg the ‘Brute Squad Moderators’ just let it pass, as long as those comments defend their baby.
Should you dare to copy/paste negative remarks in the review section of Gutenberg, you will be banned immediately by the WordPress Thought Police.
GUTENBERG EDITOR EASY? NO!
you have to take a course to understand it…
The plethora of websites now offering training and courses to ‘learn’ you how to work with Gutenberg (only $159, it’s a bargain!) should say enough about how cumbersome the ‘new vision’ of WordPress is to the average Joe. Oh wait, maybe that was the whole idea: to have businesses offering trainings for Gutenberg, so they could make a few bucks…
But, but, but, didn’t Messiah Matt promise us the new editor Gutenberg would be ‘dead simple’? According to the Gutenberg courses offered online, apparently… NOT.
WordPress: a sect
led by Messiah Matt Mullenweg
WordPress used to be a community-driven open-source project. It no longer is. It now is a project driven by an elite group of people that thinks it can do whatever they want, because WordPress powers a large part of the internet (number of websites running on the software).
In her review which by the way, surprise, surprise, has another meaningless reply from moderator ‘participant’ DesignSimply, WordPress user Vidyut writes: One really has to wonder exactly WHO it is that wanted this editor used at any cost regardless of the terrible reviews. Well, the answer to that is easy: it’s the benevolent(?) dictator for life Matt Mullenweg. The ‘boss’ of WordPress is the main force behind this.
Much more worrying is that all (Brute Squad) Moderators, Authors, Admins, Keymasters, Participants, whatever these types call themselves, are blindly following. No questions asked, or rather: questioning the road chosen is very unwelcome, your comment will be deleted and your account will be banned!
That’s ‘user input’ the WordPress way these days: censoring the users as in an autocratic society (or probably more correct: the Automattic society). It’s not only pathetic, it is extremely worrying when you think of the future of WordPress.
WordPress now feels like a religious sect, where everyone actively involved in ‘development’ of the software is blindly and totally uncritical following ‘MMM‘ (Messiah Matt Mullenweg). To them, apparently, Matt is The Way, The Truth, and The Life.
I, for one, do not want to be part of a sect. It’s absolutely disturbing and disgusting to see this happening.
- If WordPress continues on this path, WordPress is doomed.
- If WordPress continues on this path, WordPress is a dead-end street.
- If WordPress continues on this path, there’s only one way out (for now), and I’m doing that on this website and all other websites I manage: stay on WordPress version 4.9.x.
Remember the football coach that ‘will not be fired’?
he was, within 2 weeks
The only hope I have for WordPress is that the mantra by Matt and his followers (“Gutenberg is here to stay”, “Gutenberg is the future, it’s not going away”, etc.) will follow the example set by football club directors. Remember how many times they said: “We have all trust in our coach, there’s no way we will fire him! Definitely not. Really, trust us, we will not do that!”
And two weeks later, the coach is fired…
Akin to the football club: can you really keep totally ignoring your supporters? No, you cannot. Not any club, business or service can, as a giant as Coca-Cola has learned the hard way when they introduced their ‘New Coke‘. It’s even mentioned by contributors on the WordPress Forum: “Remember New Coke? It turned out to be a bad idea so they switched back.” Coca-Cola had the greatness of acknowledging their mistake. Let’s see if Messiah Matt has that same greatness. I fear not…
One wonders whatever happened to this core WordPress philosophy:
“If the next version of WordPress comes with a feature that the majority of users immediately want to turn off, or think they’ll never use, then we’ve blown it”
It took Coca-Cola a bit more than 2 weeks and I’m afraid it’ll be the same for WordPress. I suppose WordPress and Matt Mullenweg still have to learn what the hard way is, but in the end, they will. And if – unfortunately – not, then read on how to defy the ‘new vision’ of WordPress.
deny WP’s Gutenberg version
So, why is this in the ‘Tips & Tricks’ section of this website? Well, here you go, my serious advice is: don’t update to WordPress 5, stay at 4.9.x.
Ways to deny WordPress updating to version 5
If you haven’t yet updated
Add this line to your wp-config.php file (in the root of your WordPress install):
define( 'WP_AUTO_UPDATE_CORE', 'minor' );
Alternatively, you can add this line in the ‘functions.php’ file of your theme, or in a so-called ‘must use plug-in‘:
add_filter( 'allow_minor_auto_core_updates', '__return_true' );
When automatic updates are enabled, the above rules will make sure your WordPress version 4.9.x will only automatically update within that version (e.g. from 4.9.9 to 4.9.10), it will never go to the undesirable 5.x versions. In simple terms: it will automatically install security updates, but not the Gutenberg version of WordPress.
If you have already updated
If you don’t want to mess around, just install and activate the plug-in Disable Gutenberg.
It’s written by well-known and respected WordPress guru Jeff Starr, and he has vowed to keep it updated as long as needed.
DON’T install and activate the Classic Editor plug-in!!! Many people don’t realize (e.g. Thanks god Classic Editor is back as a plugin) that the team behind the Gutenberg train wreck is the same as the team behind the Classic Editor plug-in, and they might, no correction they will discontinue it at some point (the exact date of discontinuation decided by them, they’re ‘gods’ after all…).
Rolling back your WordPress version from 5.x to 4.9.x is a bit more tricky but not undoable.
- Install the WordPress plugin WP Downgrade.
- Before using this plugin make a backup of your website!
- Follow the instructions on how to downgrade. You have to fill in the exact version number of latest WordPress before version 5, at the moment, that’s 4.9.9
- If everything has gone well (and in most cases it will), you have 2 options:
- de-activate and remove the plug-in and follow the directions above under ‘If you haven’t yet updated’ (but then you still get nagged with “update to WP 5.whatever”)
- Keep the plug-in activated and be free from update nags.
All the above done? Congratulate yourself, you’re free from despicable Gutenberg!
To all people saying the above is not a secure method, I say: nonsense, as WordPress has always provided security updates to previous versions.
UNLESS WordPress at one point decides that Gutenberg is an integral part of the CMS and it cannot function without it, consequently disabling all previous versions of the software. If that’ll be the case (but I doubt WordPress will take that drastic step any time soon), there’s only one other way out left: a WordPress fork, called ClassicPress.
Do you want to immediately migrate your WordPress install to a version without Gutenberg? Follow the instructions on Switch your WordPress site to ClassicPress. It’s seamless and you are forever free of the Gutenberg disaster.
ARE WE ALONE IN DESPISING GUTENBERG?
Not at all!
One wonders whether the WordPress Gutenberg evangelists actually have any ears, whether they deliberately block them up or whether there is simply nothing between them. Because, we’re far from the only one saying: “If there ever comes a time when Gutenberg becomes a mandatory change with no alternative, we will migrate our sites to a different platform.”
Read here: WordPress Gutenberg will be the end of WordPress.
More negative reviews reading:
- 7 Reasons to Not Switch to the Gutenberg WordPress Editor: “Horribly Distracting Popups”
- 7 Golden Rules to Split and Destroy the WordPress Community (Rule 3: “The Gutenberg Block Editor Is the Only True Tool, the Classic Editor and Page Builders for the Mentally Poor”)
- Is it time to move on from WordPress? (the verdict is, YES: “It now seems like a good time to switch to a platform that’s easier to secure, easier to scale, and easier to develop on.”
- The Gutenberg Disaster: “The fallout continues and WordPress/Automattic continues to turn a deaf ear”.
- And if you’re still not convinced, just read the WordPress Gutenberg Reviews.